Comparison guide

Colorbond vs Timber Fencing: An Honest Comparison

The two most popular boundary fences in Campbelltown, compared on what actually matters: price, how long they last, upkeep, termites and rot, bush fire rules, heat, privacy, looks and what suits your block.

  • Updated 20 November 2026
  • 9 min read
  • Prices checked November 2026

Quick answer

Colorbond is the better choice for most Campbelltown boundaries: it costs from $92 per metre, lasts 20 to 30 years, needs no painting, and resists termites, rot and bush fire. Timber also starts from $92 per metre and suits established streets, curved or sloping lines and anyone who prefers a natural look, but needs more upkeep.

Key takeaways

  • Both start at about $92 per metre installed for a 1.8m fence. Lapped and capped timber and hardwood cost more.
  • Colorbond typically lasts 20 to 30 years. Treated pine palings last 10 to 15 years, hardwood 20 years or more.
  • Colorbond needs a hose-down. Timber needs a stain or oil every 3 to 5 years and the odd new paling.
  • On bush fire prone land, timber is limited to hardwood, and is ruled out within 6m of a home or at BAL-29 and above.
  • Timber can be repaired one board at a time and follows slopes and curves more easily.

Is Colorbond or Timber Fencing Better?

Colorbond is better for most suburban boundaries because it lasts longer, needs almost no maintenance and isn’t affected by termites or rot. Timber is better where you want a natural look, need to follow a curve or slope, want to repair one board at a time, or are matching fences in an established street.

Colorbond vs timber at a glance (1.8m fence, Campbelltown, guide prices incl. GST)
FactorCOLORBOND steelTimber paling
Installed price$92 – $135 /m$92 – $200 /m
Typical life20 to 30 years10 to 15 years (pine palings), 20+ (hardwood)
MaintenanceHose down occasionallyStain or oil every 3 to 5 years
Termites and rotNot affectedResisted by treatment, not immune
Bush fire prone landSuitable (non-combustible)Hardwood only, with limits
PrivacyFullFull when lapped and capped
RepairsWhole sheet or panelOne paling at a time
Slopes and curvesStepped, with plinthsRaked or stepped, easily
Look15 flat coloursNatural grain, weathers to grey

Scroll sideways to see the full table.

Neither is “best” for every block. The rest of this guide goes through each factor, so you can weigh what matters on your property: the budget, how long you plan to stay, the neighbour, the slope, and whether your block is bush fire prone.

Which Costs Less: Colorbond or Timber?

Up front, a 1.8m Colorbond fence and a basic treated pine paling fence cost about the same in Campbelltown, from $92 per metre installed. Lapped and capped pine costs $115 to $150 per metre and hardwood $135 to $200. Over 25 years, Colorbond usually costs less, because it needs no staining and fewer repairs.

Installed price per metre, 1.8m (guide prices incl. GST)
FencePrice per metre
COLORBOND steel$92 – $135
Treated pine, butted palings$92 – $120
Treated pine, lapped and capped$115 – $150
Hardwood, butted palings$135 – $175
Hardwood, lapped and capped$160 – $200

Example: the 25-year cost of a 20m back fence

An illustration using the guide prices in this article. It assumes a lapped and capped pine fence is stained by a tradesperson every 4 years and needs its palings replaced once, at about year 15.

Colorbond, installed
$1,840 – $2,700
Colorbond upkeep over 25 years
About $0 – $200
Lapped and capped pine, installed
$2,300 – $3,000
Staining, about 6 times
$1,800 – $3,600
New palings at about year 15
$1,200 – $2,600
25-year total: Colorbond vs pine
≈ $1,840 – $2,900 vs $5,300 – $9,200

If you stain the fence yourself, timber’s running costs drop a lot, and hardwood palings may last the full 25 years. Still, for most households the lifetime cost of Colorbond is lower. See current prices on our Colorbond and timber fencing pages, or every fence type in our 2026 fencing cost guide.

Which Lasts Longer: Colorbond or Timber?

A well-installed Colorbond fence typically lasts 20 to 30 years, and BlueScope offers a material warranty of up to 15 years on COLORBOND steel fencing, subject to eligibility. Treated pine palings typically last 10 to 15 years and hardwood palings 20 years or more. On both, the posts and footings decide how long the fence stays straight.

Steel sheets don’t rot, warp or split, so a Colorbond fence usually ends its life because of scratches that rust, damage from a storm or a reversing car, or posts that move. Timber palings dry out, split and warp as they weather, so a timber fence gradually loses its looks and privacy before it fails.

Posts matter more than panels

  • Colorbond posts are galvanised steel set in concrete
  • Timber posts are usually H4 treated pine, which is rated for ground contact, or galvanised steel as an upgrade for $15 to $25 per metre
  • Footings must be deep enough for the soil. The reactive clay in older parts of Campbelltown, such as Ruse, Airds and Bradbury, moves posts that are set shallow

The weak point of a timber fence

Rot and termites attack timber where it meets damp soil. Keeping mulch and garden beds below the bottom of the palings, and choosing steel posts, adds years to a timber fence.

Which Needs Less Maintenance?

Colorbond needs very little maintenance: an occasional hose-down, keeping soil and mulch off the bottom of the sheets, and touching up deep scratches. Timber needs a stain or oil every 3 to 5 years to slow weathering, plus checks for loose palings, rot at ground level and termite activity.

Looking after a Colorbond fence

  • Hose off dust and garden spray now and then, especially on the lower edge
  • Keep soil, mulch and garden beds from building up against the sheets
  • Aim sprinklers away from the fence, because constant wetting stains and shortens its life
  • Touch up deep scratches with matching touch-up paint to stop rust starting

Looking after a timber fence

  • Stain or oil every 3 to 5 years, more often on sunny, exposed sides
  • Replace split or loose palings before the gaps grow
  • Keep soil and mulch below the bottom of the palings and plinth
  • Check for termite mud tubes on posts and rails, especially in older suburbs

How Do Termites, Rot and Rust Affect Each Fence?

Colorbond steel can’t be eaten by termites and doesn’t rot, but scratched or cut edges can rust if they stay wet. Treated pine resists termites and rot because of its preservative treatment under AS 1604, but cut ends and untreated parts are vulnerable. Durable hardwoods resist decay naturally, depending on the species.

How each material handles pests and weather
ThreatCOLORBOND steelTreated pineHardwood
TermitesImmuneResisted by treatmentDepends on species
RotNot affectedResisted; cut ends vulnerableDurable species resist well
RustAt deep scratches and cut edgesNot applicable (check nails)Not applicable (check nails)
Sun and weatherColour fades slowlyGreys, splits and warpsGreys, checks slowly

Scroll sideways to see the full table.

Under AS 1604, treated pine is graded by where it will be used: H3 for timber above the ground, such as palings and rails, and H4 for timber in the ground, such as posts and plinths. A good timber fence uses the right grade for each part. Ask what treatment level your quote includes.

Which Fence Is Better on Bush Fire Prone Land?

Colorbond is better on bush fire prone land because steel is non-combustible. Under Planning for Bush Fire Protection 2019, new fences on bush fire prone land must be hardwood or non-combustible, and within 6m of a building, or at BAL-29 and above, they must be non-combustible. That rules out treated pine, and often timber altogether.

Parts of Kentlyn, Wedderburn, Gilead and Appin, and the bushland edges of suburbs such as St Helens Park, Ruse and Glen Alpine, are mapped as bush fire prone. If your block is mapped, check the rules before you choose a fence. Colorbond is the usual answer, and COLORBOND steel is one of the most common fences in these areas for this reason.

  • Check whether your property is bush fire prone with Campbelltown City Council or the NSW Rural Fire Service
  • If it is, treated pine palings are not permitted for new fences
  • Hardwood may be permitted, except within 6m of a building or at BAL-29 and above
  • Steel fences such as COLORBOND are non-combustible and suit every bush fire level

Which Gives Better Privacy and Noise Reduction?

At 1.8m, both a Colorbond fence and a lapped and capped timber fence give full privacy. Butted timber palings open small gaps as they dry. For noise, a fence with no gaps blocks more sound than one with gaps, and height matters more than material. Neither is a rated acoustic barrier.

Colorbond sheets are solid from bottom rail to top rail, so there are no gaps to see through. Lapped and capped timber achieves the same by overlapping the palings. Butted palings sit side by side and shrink as they dry, so you can often see through a butted fence within a year or two.

For traffic noise, close the gap at the bottom of the fence with a plinth, keep the fence at the full 1.8m, and avoid gaps at posts and gates. Both materials reduce some noise. Solid steel can transmit the sound of rain and balls hitting it, which some owners notice more than with timber.

Do Colorbond Fences Get Hot in Summer?

Yes. Dark Colorbond colours such as Monument and Woodland Grey absorb more sun and can become hot to touch on summer days, and they reflect some of that heat onto nearby plants. Light colours such as Surfmist and Shale Grey stay cooler. Timber doesn’t heat up as much as dark steel.

In western Sydney summers this is worth thinking about if the fence faces north or west, if children play against it, or if you plan a vegetable bed beside it. Choosing a lighter colour on hot sides, or planting a hedge a little away from the fence, makes a noticeable difference.

Our Colorbond fence colours guide compares all 15 colours, including how each handles heat, dust and fading.

Which Looks Better and Adds More Value?

Colorbond gives a clean, uniform look that suits newer estates, and buyers generally see it as low maintenance. Timber suits established streets and older homes, and a new hardwood fence looks premium. Some newer estates set fence types and colours in their design guidelines, so check before you choose.

In newer Macarthur estates such as Gregory Hills, Oran Park and Edmondson Park, COLORBOND in a mid or dark grey is the most common boundary fence, and some estates specify fence types or colours in their design guidelines or covenants. In established suburbs such as Bradbury, Leumeah and Ruse, timber paling fences are still common, and matching the neighbouring fences can look better than introducing steel.

For resale, a straight, sound fence matters more than the material. A leaning timber fence with missing palings or a dented, rusting steel fence both drag on first impressions.

What If You and Your Neighbour Want Different Fences?

Under the Dividing Fences Act 1991 (NSW), neighbours share the cost of a sufficient dividing fence, usually half each. If one of you wants a dearer fence, such as hardwood or a taller Colorbond fence, that neighbour usually pays the difference. Both sides of the fence face someone, so agree on the material and colour in writing.

A “sufficient” fence depends on things like the existing fence and other fences in the area. In a street of timber paling fences, a standard pine paling fence may be sufficient. In an estate of Colorbond fences, a standard Colorbond fence usually is. Our guide Who Pays for a Boundary Fence in NSW? explains fencing notices and disputes.

Which side faces out?

A timber fence has a rail side and a smooth side, and by convention the smooth side faces the neighbour or the street. Most COLORBOND fences look the same, or almost the same, from both sides, which helps when neighbours share the cost.

Which Works Better on a Sloping or Curved Boundary?

Timber is easier on slopes and curves, because rails and palings can be cut to follow the ground in a smooth, raked line. Colorbond panels are usually stepped down a slope, with concrete or steel plinths filling the triangular gaps underneath. Both work well when the job is planned properly.

On a gentle slope, a stepped Colorbond fence looks tidy and keeps each panel level. On a steeper or uneven slope, timber can follow the ground closely without leaving gaps. Where the ground drops sharply, a retaining wall may be needed first. Our sloping block guide compares stepped and raked fences in detail.

How Do You Choose Between Colorbond and Timber?

Choose Colorbond if you want the lowest upkeep, the longest life, protection from termites, or your block is bush fire prone. Choose timber if you want a natural look, need to follow curves or slopes, are matching an established street, or want to repair one board at a time. Many homes use both.

Choose Colorbond if…

you want a fence you can mostly forget about, the block is bush fire prone, termites are active in the area, or you are in a newer estate.

Choose timber if…

you prefer a natural look, the line curves or slopes, the street has timber fences, or you want to replace single boards over time.

Use both

Colorbond on side and rear boundaries, with a timber or slat feature fence at the front, is a popular mix.

Still unsure?

An installer can show you both on site, check the slope and soil, and price each so you can compare.

Other options worth a look: aluminium slat fencing for a modern front fence, and brushwood for a natural garden screen.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you mix Colorbond and timber on the same property?

Yes. A common approach is Colorbond on the side and rear boundaries for low maintenance, and timber or aluminium slat at the front for looks. Matching the post colour and height across the fences keeps it tidy.

Which fence is better for dogs?

Both work at 1.8m. Colorbond is harder for dogs to chew or push through and has no gaps to see through, which can reduce barking. Timber can be chewed, but is easy to repair. For diggers, add a plinth or a concrete edge along the bottom.

Which is better for the environment?

Each has advantages. Steel is long-lasting and recyclable at the end of its life. Plantation pine and certified hardwood are renewable, but treated timber can’t be burned or composted and must be disposed of properly. A fence that lasts longer generally has less impact over time.

How long does each take to install?

A 20m Colorbond fence usually takes about a day once the posts are in. A timber paling fence of the same length takes one to two days, a little longer for lapped and capped or hardwood.

Can an old timber fence be replaced with Colorbond on the same line?

Yes. The old fence is removed, which usually costs $20 to $40 per metre, new steel posts are set in concrete on the same boundary line, and the panels are fitted. Agree on the change with your neighbour first if it’s a dividing fence.

Sources

  1. COLORBOND steel (BlueScope) (opens in a new tab)
  2. Planning for Bush Fire Protection (NSW Rural Fire Service) (opens in a new tab)
  3. AS 1604.1 Preservative-treated wood products (Standards Australia) (opens in a new tab)
  4. Dividing Fences Act 1991 (NSW) (opens in a new tab)
  5. Exempt development: fences (NSW Planning Portal) (opens in a new tab)

Related services and guides